New York City

• Portero
• 49 Matt Freese
• Defensa
• 34 Raul Gustavo
• 13 Thiago Martina
• 22 Kevin O'Toole
• 24 Tayvon Gray 89'
• Centrocampista
• 26 Agustín Ojeda 83'
• 17 Hannes Wolf 71'
• 5 Kai Trewin
• 21 Aiden O'Neill
• 10 Maxi Moralez 71'
• Delantero
• 7 Nicolás Fernández x2 83'

• Banquillo
• ent Pascal Jansen 4-2-3-1
• 19 Strahinja Tanasijevic (89')
• 99 Seymour Reid
• 32 Jonathan Shore (83')
• 2 Nico Cavallo
• 87 Arnau Farnós (83')
• 55 Keaton Parks (71')
• 29 Máximo Carrizo
• 11 Talles Magno (71')
• 30 Tomás Romero

FC Cincinnati

• Portero
• 18 Roman Celentano
• Defensa
• 3 Gilberto Flores 59'
• 15 Teenage Hadebe 22'
• 24 Kyle Smith
• Centrocampista
• 17 Kenji Mboma Dem
• 11 Samuel Gidi
• 66 Ender Echenique 59'
• 20 Pavel Bucha
• Delantero
• 9 Ahoueke Denkey x2
• 16 Tom Barlow 82'
• 10 Evander Ferreira

• Banquillo
• ent Pat Noonan 3-4-1-2
• 22 Gerardo Valenzuela (59')
• 88 Andrei Chirila (45')
• 27 Brian Anunga (59')
• 2 Alvas Powell (45')
• 13 Evan Louro
• 99 Ayoub Jabbari (82')
• 37 Stiven Jimenez