New York Red Bulls

• Portero
• 34 Ethan Horvath
• Defensa
• 12 Dylan Nealis
• 3 Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty
• 56 Matthew Dos Santos 69'
• 6 Robert Voloder
• Centrocampista
• 10 Forsberg 85'
• 48 Ronald Donkor
• 15 Adri Mehmeti 79'
• Delantero
• 7 Cade Cowell 69'
• 11 Jorge Ruvalcaba 79'
• 16 Julian Hall

• Banquillo
• ent Michael Bradley 4-3-3
• 37 Mohammed Sofo (79')
• 77 John McCarthy
• 79 Rafael Mosquera
• 20 Juan Mina
• 39 Nehuén Benedetti (79')
• 66 Tanner Rosborough (69')
• 26 Tim Parker
• 13 Choupo-Moting (85')
• 5 Omar Valencia (69')

FC Cincinnati

• Portero
• 13 Evan Louro
• Defensa
• 29 Bryan Ramírez
• 24 Kyle Smith 74'
• 4 Nick Hagglund 74'
• 21 Matt Miazga 83'
• Centrocampista
• 20 Pavel Bucha
• 11 Samuel Gidi 66'
• 16 Tom Barlow 74'
• 66 Ender Echenique
• Delantero
• 9 Ahoueke Denkey
• 10 Evander Ferreira

• Banquillo
• ent Pat Noonan 4-4-2
• 93 Fabian Mrozek
• 88 Andrei Chirila
• 27 Brian Anunga (66')
• 5 Obinna Nwobodo
• 17 Kenji Mboma Dem (74')
• 3 Gilberto Flores
• 2 Alvas Powell (74')
• 15 Teenage Hadebe (74')
• 99 Ayoub Jabbari (83')