Columbus Crew

• Portero
• 1 Nicholas Hagen
• Defensa
• 25 Sean Zawadzki
• 2 Andrés Herrera
• 4 Rudy Camacho 63'
• 31 Steven Moreira 75'
• Centrocampista
• 20 André Gomes
• 90 Nariman Akhundzada 63'
• 27 Max Arfsten
• 17 Sékou Bangoura 75'
• Delantero
• 16 Taha Habroune 75'
• 10 Diego Rossi

• Banquillo
• ent Laurent Courtois 4-4-2
• 23 Mohamed Farsi (75')
• 19 Jamal Thiaré (75')
• 21 Yevhen Cheberko (63')
• 14 Amar Sejdic
• 30 Hugo Picard (63')
• 24 Evan Bush
• 7 Dylan Chambost (75')

New York City

• Portero
• 49 Matt Freese
• Defensa
• 13 Thiago Martina
• 2 Nico Cavallo
• 24 Tayvon Gray
• 34 Raul Gustavo
• Centrocampista
• 32 Jonathan Shore
• 5 Kai Trewin 86'
• 8 Andrés Perea 63'
• Delantero
• 26 Agustín Ojeda 63'
• 17 Hannes Wolf 63'
• 7 Nicolás Fernández 63'

• Banquillo
• ent Pascal Jansen 4-3-3
• 99 Seymour Reid (63')
• 30 Tomás Romero
• 15 Kevin Pierre
• 88 Malachi Jones (63')
• 19 Strahinja Tanasijevic (86')
• 29 Máximo Carrizo (63')
• 87 Arnau Farnós (63')