New York City
- Portero
- 49 Matt Freese
- Defensa
- 13 Thiago Martina
- 2 Nico Cavallo
- 34 Raul Gustavo
- 24 Tayvon Gray
- Centrocampista
- 17 Hannes Wolf x3 (84')
- 5 Kai Trewin
- 10 Maxi Moralez (90')
- 55 Keaton Parks (84')
- 26 Agustín Ojeda (87')
- Delantero
- 7 Nicolás Fernández (91')
- Banquillo
- ent Pascal Jansen 4-2-3-1
- 29 Máximo Carrizo (90')
- 88 Malachi Jones (84')
- 87 Arnau Farnós (87')
- 18 Greg Ranjitsingh
- 15 Kevin Pierre
- 32 Jonathan Shore (84')
- 99 Seymour Reid (91')
- 30 Tomás Romero
- 19 Strahinja Tanasijevic
Columbus Crew
- Portero
- 28 Patrick Schulte
- Defensa
- 31 Steven Moreira (67')
- 2 Andrés Herrera
- 25 Sean Zawadzki
- 4 Rudy Camacho
- Centrocampista
- 20 André Gomes (67')
- 30 Hugo Picard (78')
- 7 Dylan Chambost (78')
- 27 Max Arfsten
- Delantero
- 10 Diego Rossi
- 16 Taha Habroune (67')
- Banquillo
- ent Henrik Rydström 4-4-2
- 14 Amar Sejdic (78')
- 21 Yevhen Cheberko
- 46 Chase Adams
- 8 Daniel Gazdag (67')
- 1 Nicholas Hagen
- 12 Cesar Ruvalcaba
- 17 Sékou Bangoura (67')
- 23 Mohamed Farsi (67')
- 90 Nariman Akhundzada (78')