Chicago Fire
- Portero
- 1 Christopher Brady
- Defensa
- 15 Andrew Gutman
- 24 Jonathan Dean (79')
- 3 Jack Elliott
- 16 Joel Waterman
- Centrocampista
- 11 Philip Zinckernagel
- 42 Djé D'Avilla (79')
- 19 Jonathan Bamba (60')
- 6 Anton Salétros (79')
- 7 Maren Haile-Selassie (85')
- Delantero
- 9 Hugo Cuypers
- Banquillo
- ent Gregg Berhalter 4-2-3-1
- 4 Mbekezeli Mbokazi
- 20 Jason Shokalook (79')
- 27 Dylan Borso (85')
- 44 Josh Cohen
- 22 Mauricio Pineda (79')
- 8 Christopher Mueller
- 14 Viktor Radojevic
- 12 Puso Dithejane (60')
- 35 Sergio Oregel Jr. (79')
New York Red Bulls
- Portero
- 34 Ethan Horvath
- Defensa
- 26 Tim Parker
- 12 Dylan Nealis
- 6 Robert Voloder (79')
- 56 Matthew Dos Santos (72')
- Centrocampista
- 11 Jorge Ruvalcaba
- 48 Ronald Donkor
- 7 Cade Cowell (72')
- 10 Forsberg (59')
- 15 Adri Mehmeti
- Delantero
- 16 Julian Hall (45')
- Banquillo
- ent Michael Bradley 4-1-4-1
- 2 Justin Che (79')
- 77 John McCarthy
- 79 Rafael Mosquera (72')
- 3 Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty
- 5 Omar Valencia (72')
- 4 Gustav Berggren (59')
- 37 Mohammed Sofo
- 13 Choupo-Moting (45')
- 39 Nehuén Benedetti