Westchester
- Portero
- 13 Andrew Hammersley
- Defensa
- 5 Timofey Timchenko (75')
- 66 Noah Powder (45')
- 2 Maximus Jennings (60')
- 4 Bobby Pierre
- Centrocampista
- 21 Aleksei Armas (45')
- 83 Kyle Evans
- 6 Conor McGlynn
- Delantero
- 27 Jonathan Jiménez
- 10 Dean Guezen (60')
- 77 Daniel Burko
- Banquillo
- ent George Gjokaj 4-3-3
- 18 Ermin Mackic (60')
- 8 Daniel Bouman (45')
- 3 Charlie Dickerson (45')
- 7 Samory Powder (60')
- 11 Bryan Vásquez
- 9 Koen Blommestijn (75')
- 23 Matías Molina
New York City
- Portero
- 30 Tomás Romero
- Defensa
- 34 Raul Gustavo
- 24 Tayvon Gray
- 2 Nico Cavallo (85')
- 5 Kai Trewin
- Centrocampista
- 32 Jonathan Shore
- 11 Talles Magno x3 (85')
- 15 Kevin Pierre
- Delantero
- 99 Seymour Reid (85')
- 26 Agustín Ojeda (67')
- 87 Arnau Farnós
- Banquillo
- ent Pascal Jansen 4-3-3
- 18 Greg Ranjitsingh
- 7 Nicolás Fernández (85')
- 55 Keaton Parks
- 45 Kamran Acito (85')
- 88 Malachi Jones (67')
- 29 Máximo Carrizo (85')
- 17 Hannes Wolf